Reading the articles that were assigned for week three allowed for a deeper evaluation of what I would do as a teacher in many situations. I was first struck by the article by Cusumano. She gave us a sample writing by a 5 year-old student and evaluated it on many levels. Before reading her evaluation, I too took a look at the writing that this child did, and in my head evaluated it from the beginning. After completing the article I was shocked to find out how brilliant this child truly was, and how easily it can be overlooked.
- drawing along with writing
- writing from left to right
- flexible shapes of letters
- spaces between words
- multiple spellings for words
- a special mark at the end
All of these practices were included in the 5 year-olds writing showing her knowledge of the very complex topics on a basic level. Thinking about how children understand these conventions and can apply them to their work shows the importance of freedoms that teachers give to children. At such a young age, writing on lines, proper spelling, capitalization, and many other aspects of writing that are required in the later years, are not important. Although I am not sure if I will be teaching children of that age level, it requires me to think about whatever level of students I will be teaching and how I can apply this to them as well. If teaching students of a 1st through 3rd grade level, there will be a very wide range of writers. Knowing each students abilities can show what should be expected of them. Working off what they can practice they will be able to grow at a better rate than throwing them into the writing of different abilities so that I can "Provide praise and
encouragement for the ideas without criticizing the errors in conventions."
I felt like you did after reading the article, Cusumano revealed much more complex writing than I saw the first time in the 5 year old's sample!
ReplyDeleteI like your approach and the articles to reading, because I don't feel like all that criticism will help at all anyway! We want students to feel like they can try new things with their writing and not be restricted by grammar rules, or they might not want to try anymore.
I was also surprised how complex the 5 year old's writing sample was. I also agree that providing students with so much criticism won't really be beneficial because as a teacher we don't want to discourage our students.
ReplyDelete